
With this week's release of "Guerolito," a complete album remix of the earlier album, "Guero" by Beck, I thought it might be fun to consider if the remix album is overall a better album than the original. When I first picked up "Guerolito," it doesn't necessarily sound like a "remix" album, and the tracks aren't all 10 minutes long, so it's a fair comparison. Also, I'm excluding any bonus tracks and "Clap Hands" because it's not a remix.
1. "E-Pro" vs. "Ghost Range (E-Pro)"
The original "E-Pro" is a boozy guitar rocker, an all-around classic Beck track. However, "Ghost Range (E-Pro)" is a strange hoe-down, drum-machine and 70's television show soundtrack. For creativity alone, I have to give the first round to Guerolito. Remixer Homelife did a great job on this one.
2. "Que Onda Guero" vs. "Que Onda Guero (remix)"
With a laid-back, oldschool type vibe, the original track stands well on it's own. A suitable 3rd of 4th single even. The remix adds a Salsa type flavour, and a pile of acoustic guitars. The remixers Islands however, lose points by being the first guys to "screw" a song for a little while, and not make it effective. While it's a good remix, this round goes to
Guero.
3. "Girl" vs. "Girl (remix)"

The original is an upbeat blippy keyboard and acoustic guitar track, and features a cool slide guitar solo. The remix by Octet replaces the guitars with keyboards and pianos, and puts in some loud drums. Now, it begins to sound like a remix near the end of the remix with the IDM style beats and the chopped up and reversed vocal, but overall, the remix is better. Mark another for
Guerolito.
4. "Missing" vs. "Heaven Hammer (Missing)"
Another song with a cool latino beat on the original album, Beck lays down a cool rap and fills the track with lush orchestral sounds. The remix by Air turns the track into a typical synthy low-key Air song with a delayed drum machine beat. This is a hard one to pick but I'm going to go with
Guero on this one.
5. "Black Tambourine" vs. "Shake Shake Tambourine (Black Tambourine)"
Beck returns to a funky style beat with "Black Tambourine," which is fairly straight-ahead groovy number. However, Beasite Boy Adrock turned in an amazing mix that takes the track into the groove stratosphere. Obvious win here for
Guerolito.
6. "Earthquake Weather" vs. "Terremoto Tempo (Earthquake Moto)"
Another slow burn groove track from Beck, with a nice beat and some cool keyboards, breaks down pretty well, and seems like it would be hard to improve. Mario C pushes the beat to the forefront in the remix, and makes Beck's voice louder on the chorus, which overall adds to the song's distressing urgency. Another obvious win for
Guerolito.
7. "Hell Yes" vs. "Ghettochip Malfunction (Hell Yes)"
The original version of "Hell Yes" is almost classic. It's unique beat with a killer bassline and an awesome rap. Remixer 8 bit lives up to his name and turns the track into an all-out robot jam, easily a superior version. Win goes to
Guerolito.
8. "Broken Drum" vs. "Broken Drum (remix)"
Through an opium-hazed dirge, Beck's vocal float along through "Broken Drum" with the help of a dusty slide guitar. When Boards of Canada take over, they give the track an expansive backbeat and fill it out with a landscape of sound. The outro alone gives
Guerolito the win.
9. "Scarecrow" vs. "Scarecrow (remix)"
Beck brings Guero back up to speed when he pulls out this drive track complete with "ooh-ooh" backup vocals. It's a soulful romp with an amazing wah-wah harmonica at the end. El-P really twists everything around until it's recognizable, slowing it down, and even taking away the soulful quality of the song. While neither version is particularily exciting, the jam gives the original the upper hand; mark one for
Guero.
10. "Go it Alone" vs. "Wish Coin (Go it Alone)"
On Guero, "Go it Alone" perfectly compliments "Scarecrow" before, following things up with another guitar-based groovy jam. The remix by Superthriller frames the entire song in a dubish kind of beat, and while it's cool on it's own, Beck does it better.
Guero.
11. "Farewell Ride" vs. "Farewell Ride (remix)"
Another cool drum beat, more interesting guitar riffs, and a great big end of song jam. It's the kind of song that Beck shows off his talent, no for being quirky, but just pure musicianship. The remix for the track by Subtle tends to lag a bit, but wins major cool points when for a couple mintues it sounds like crunk. But the remix is a little too unfocused, so the win goes to
Guero.
12. "Rental Car" vs. "Rental Car by John King"
The upbeat "Rental Car" is a fun light rock song, which takes a cool left turn near the end. But when the Dust Brothers take over the remix, they chill everything down and then inject it with life. Win goes to
Guerolito, obviously.
13. "Emergency Exit" vs. "Emergency Exit"
This is the official final track on Guero, and Beck definately goes out with a bang. It's big and cocky, and there's not much you can do to not love this one. Remixers Th' Corn Gangg actually remix the song "Broken Drum." It's sped up and pretty cool, but in the nature of this contest, it can't beat the original. Point to
Guero.
Final Tally:
Guero: 6
Guerolito: 7
I'm actually suprised about how close the final score is. At the beginning it looked like Beck was a goner for sure, but with a late-album rally, he showed off that he is the master of his domain. However, it does prove that Beck should invite some producers in to his sessions to add some extra flavour to his songs. If you're like me, as a result of this list, you'll make a "Perfect Guero" playist combining all the winners. Thanks for playing!